Unfortunately no one can be told what fun_plug is - you have to see it for yourself.
You are not logged in.
Moving into a shared office space and before I get my IP address setup which I will assign to my router, I am curious as to which of these solutions will work. Assuming I want to put a device like a DNS-323 off of my DIR-655 router, accessible via FTP by public users. Any pro's and con's of these 3 setups.
1. Dynamic IP Address
2. Static IP Address from Internal Network 192.168.xxx.xxx
3. Static IP Address from Public Internet, and opening up ports
on the office Firewall.
Offline
1. I wouldn't assign dynamic addresses to server components like the NAS. You would at least need to make sure that your DNS server knows the address of the NAS to be able to reach it via its name. You could as well use DHCP and assign the NAS a fixed address via DHCP.
2. The static address from an internal network is probably the best of your scenarios because you would conceal the NAS from the outside world and would only need to forward one port from you router to the NAS.
3. I wouldn't expose the NAS directly to the Internet. You have no way to patch the firmware and all security holes can be abused by the outside world if they have direct access to the NAS.
You could put the NAS in a DMZ between you internet access router and your company firewall. That would be the safest solution but will require additional hardware.
Offline
Thanks SilverSurfer,
I'm glad that the static IP on an internal network is best according to your recommendation, since that is what was initally setup for me in my shared office. I don't logically understand though how can the outside world find it though if the IP address of my router is an internal IP 192.168.xx.xx.
Offline
netmation wrote:
Thanks SilverSurfer,
I'm glad that the static IP on an internal network is best according to your recommendation, since that is what was initally setup for me in my shared office. I don't logically understand though how can the outside world find it though if the IP address of my router is an internal IP 192.168.xx.xx.
The outside world connects to the public ip address of your router and is then forwarded to the internal ip address of your DNS-323.
See www.portforward.com
Offline
Sorry for my confusion. The situation is that I am in an office building, shared by several businesses, that has a router with a public IP address. In my specific individual office, I have a Dlink DIR-655, where they assigned me an internal Static IP address 192.168.xx.xx. I want to put a DNS-323 off of my DIR-655. The question is do I have to get a public IP address assigned to my DIR-655 for this to work? Would that be required and recommended? Thanks for all your help.
Offline
I think I may need to go into a little more detailed explanation here.
Any router connecting to the internet must have a public ip address on it's external interface - it may have a public ip address (from a different subnet) or it may have a private ip address on the internal interface.
If both interfaces have public ip addresses, the router will have specific routing tables that tell it how to "route" the ip traffic as required, but if the internal interface has a private ip address, then a process known as NAT or Network Address Translation will be used to share the single public ip address amongst several private ip addresses.
Most small businesses use NAT routers
If your DIR-655 has a 192.168.x.x address on it's WAN interface, then there is a very good chance that the office complex you are in is using a NAT router to share the public ip address - you would need to configure this router to forward the appropriate port to your router (the DIR-655), and then you would need to configure your router (the DIR-655) to forward the port to the DNS-323.
An easier way might be to configure the first router so that your router (the DIR-655) is in it's DMZ (De Militarized Zone).
Obviously this will need access to the first router and the problem you may face will be a "conflict" with another occupant needing to use the same port as you do.
Offline
Thanks for the lenghty explanation, it does help. The only question I am really trying answer though is would it be better for me to get a private 192.168.xx.xx static IP on my DIR-655. Or get a public internet static IP. The office complex is giving me both choices. I would like to cause the least burden to the office complex and their security concerns.
Currently I have the DIR-655 assigned a private 192.168.xx.xx static IP. From what you said this would easily work, assuming I inform the office complex to forward the proper port to my static IP address?
Offline
If you can get a public ip for your router's WAN interface - do it - it'll make your life easier.
Offline